In terms of American folklore, the sheriff is a glamorous and heroic official who protects the innocent. The name comes from two English words, "shire" which means "county," and "reeve" which means "administrator." May he be considered a superman, because the requirements of his job necessitate that he be a law-man, a leader, a fighter, a diplomat, a lawyer, a detective, a doctor, a politician, plus a few other qualifications his job may require. However, he is a human being like the rest of us. Here is a look at some of the men who have been the Sheriff of Navarro County.
 James Buckner Barry Served 8/1850 - 1852 8/1854 - 1855
|
 Jessie Simeon Walton Served 8/1855 - 11/1860
|
 Lafford Berry (Dick) French Served 1865 - 1866
|
 Jesse Rascoe Interim 4/1870 - 7/1870
|
 Samuel John Thomas Johnson Served 1/1873 - 8/1876
|
 Ewing E. Dunn Served 4/1876 - 11/1884
|
 James Lanier Walton Served 11/1884 - 11/1886
|
 Wiley D. Robinson, Sr. Served 1900-1902 1904-1906
|
 Jonas Joshua Hail, Jr. Served 1902 - 1904 1906 - 1908
|
 Mastifer (Michael) Steele Clayton Served 11/1908 - 11/1912
|
 Walter Lavosier Pevehouse Served 11/1912 - 11/1916
|
 John Richard Curington Served 11/1916 - 11/1920
|
 Walter Hayes Served 11/1920 - 11/1924
|
 John E. Stewart Served 11/1924 - 11/1926
|
 Rufus H. Pevehouse Served 11/1928 - 11/1938 11/1950 - 11/1972
|
 Calvin O. (Cap) Curington Served 11/1938 - 11/1946
|
 David S. Castles Served 11/1946 - 11/1950
|
 Jerry N. Shelton 1/1973 - 5/1979
|
 Henry Harold Pitts Served 5/1979 - 2/1980
|
 Pete McCain Served 2/1980 - 1/1986
|
 Robert (Bobby) Nelson Ross Served 11/1980 - 12/1984
|
 James (Jim) Persons Hodge, Jr. Served 1/1985 - 12/1992
|
 Leslie A. Cotten, Sr. Served 1/1993 - 12/2012
|
 Elmer Tanner Served 1/2013 - Present
|